Endoscopic stenting for inoperable malignant biliary obstruction: A systematic review and meta-analy

来源 :World Journal of Gastroenterology | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:djseagle
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
AIM: To analyze through meta-analyses the benefits of two types of stents in the inoperable malignant biliary obstruction.METHODS: A systematic review of randomized clinical trials(RCT) was conducted, with the last update on March 2015, using EMBASE, CINAHL(EBSCO), MEDLINE, LILACS/CENTRAL(BVS), SCOPUS, CAPES(Brazil), and gray literature. Information of the selected studies was extracted in sight of six outcomes: primarily regarding dysfunction, complication and reintervention rates; and secondarily costs, survival, and patency time. The data about characteristics of trial participants, inclusion and exclusion criteria and types of stents were also extracted. The bias was mainly assessed through the JADAD scale. This meta-analysis was registered in the PROSPERO database by the number CRD42014015078. The analysis of the absolute risk of the outcomes was performed using the software Rev Man, by computing risk differences(RD) of dichotomous variables and mean differences(MD) of continuous variables. Data on RD and MD for each primary outcome were calculated using the MantelHaenszel test and inconsistency was qualified and reported in χ2 and the Higgins method(I2). Sensitivity analysis was performed when heterogeneity was higher than 50%, a subsequent assay was done and other findings were compiled. Student’s t-test was used for the comparison of weighted arithmetic means regarding secondary outcomes.RESULTS: Initial searching identified 3660 studies; 3539 were excluded through title, repetition, and/or abstract, while 121 studies were fully assessed and were excluded mainly because they did not compare self-expanding metal stents(SEMS) and plastic stents(PS), leading to thirteen RCT selected, with 13 articles and 1133 subjects meta-analyzed. The mean age was 69.5 years old, that were affected mostly by bile duct(proximal) and pancreatic tumors(distal). The preferred SEMS diameter used was the 10 mm(30 Fr) and the preferred PS diameter used was 10 Fr. In the metaanalysis, SEMS had lower overall stent dysfunction compared to PS(21.6% vs 46.8%, P < 0.00001) and fewer re-interventions(21.6% vs 56.6%, P < 0.00001), with no difference in complications(13.7% vs 15.9%, P = 0.16). In the secondary analysis, the mean survival rate was higher in the SEMS group(182 d vs 150 d, P < 0.0001), with a higher patency period(250 d vs 124 d, P < 0.0001) and a lower cost per patient(4193.98 vs 4728.65 Euros, P < 0.0985).CONCLUSION: SEMS are associated with lower stent dysfunction, lower re-intervention rates, better survival, and higher patency time. Complications and costs showed no difference. AIM: To analyze through meta-analyses the benefits of two types of stents in the inoperable malignant biliary obstruction. METHODS: A systematic review of randomized clinical trials (RCT) was conducted, with the last update on March 2015, using EMBASE, CINAHL ( EBSCO), MEDLINE, LILACS / CENTRAL (BVS), SCOPUS, CAPES (Brazil), and gray literature. Information of the selected studies were extracted in sight of six outcomes: concerned regarding dysfunction, complication and reinvention rates; The data about characteristics of trial participants, inclusion and exclusion criteria and types of stents were also extracted. The bias was mainly assessed through the JADAD scale. This meta-analysis was registered in the PROSPERO database by the number CRD42014015078. The analysis of the absolute risk of the outcomes was performed using the software Rev Man, by computing risk differences (RD) of dichotomous variables and mean differences (MD) of continuous variables. Data on RD and MD for each primary outcome were calculated using the ManHaenszel test and inconsistency was qualified and reported in χ2 and the Higgins method (I2). Sensitivity analysis was performed when heterogeneity was higher than 50%, a subsequent assay was done Student’s t-test was used for the comparison of weighted arithmetic means regarding secondary outcomes.RESULTS: Initial searches identified 3660 studies; 3539 were excluded through title, repetition, and / or abstract, while 121 studies were fully evaluated and were excluded primarily because they did not compare self-expanding metal stents (SEMS) and plastic stents (PS), leading to thirteen RCT selected, with 13 articles and 1133 subjects meta-analyzed. The mean age was 69.5 years old, that were The preferred SEM diameter was used for the 10 mm (30 Fr) and the preferred PS diameter used was 10 Fr. In the metaanalysi s, SEMS had lower overall stent dysfunction compared to PS (21.6% vs 46.8%, P <0.00001) and fewer re-interventions (21.6% vs 56.6%, P <0.00001) with no difference in complications (13.7% vs 15.9% P = 0.16). In the secondary analysis, the mean survival rate was higher in the SEMS group (182 d vs 150 d, P <0.0001), with a higher patency period (250 d vs 124 d, P <0.0001) and a lower cost per patient (4193.98 vs 4728.65 Euros, P <0.0985) .CONCLUSION: SEMS are associated with lower stent dysfunction, lower re-intervention rates, better survival, and higher patency time. Complications and costs showed no difference.
其他文献
东北虎也叫西伯利亚虎。历史上曾经广泛活动在中国东北的各个林区,近几十年来,由于人口密度的不断增加和森林的过度砍伐等原因,东北虎正受到生存环境丧失和食物资源匮乏的严
社会主义市场经济的迅速发展,促使我们对督查工作方式作适应性调整。经过一年多摸索,我们初步形成了以实施党委宏观决策督查为主体,以解决决策与实际结合中的矛盾为基本着力
西部大开发,为兵团的电视事业提供了新的发展环境。我们必须抓住机遇开拓进取,在西部开发中让全国人民了解兵团,支持兵团,使兵团的电视事业在西部大开发中成为新的亮点,发挥
目的:探讨甲状腺癌中HIF-1α和VEGF蛋白的表达及其意义。 方法:收集河北省人民医院2001年6月至2006年6月手术切除的甲状腺病变患者148例。其中甲状腺乳头状癌患者50例,男9例,
墨子的学生子禽问墨子道:“多说话有好处吗?” 墨子答复说:“像癞蛤蟆与青蛙,从早到晚不停地叫,甚至叫到口干舌燥,然而有谁听到它们的叫声呢?反观报晓的雄鸡, Mozi student
《文件处置办法》拟制于1931年2月,是党的文书处理工作最早的系统规定,是建立党的档案工作的第一个重要文献。领导的关怀《文件处置办法》是在中共中央政治局常委周恩来 Th
以中国春小麦品种中8601、澳大利亚栽培小麦品种Sunstar、Millewa作母本,与抗大麦黄矮病毒病(BarleyYellowDwarfVirus,简称BYDV)的小麦-中间偃麦草异附加系L1杂交,取杂种的幼胚和幼穗作离体培养,获得大量再生植株。经酶联免疫吸附分
Background and Objectives: Search for inexpensive laboratory markers have identified associations between blood counts and lung cancer outcomes. In this study,
为提高公文处理的质量和效率、充分发挥公文的施政作用,确保公文的权威性、时效性和准确性,必须严格办文程序。(一)严格拟发文稿审核程序。公文能否严格审核把关,决定着公文
张建利,男,湖南科技学院美术系副教授、党总支书记,湖南省摄影家协会会员,湖南高校摄影学会常务理事。长期从事风光摄影创作,作品先后在第十五届佳能杯“亚洲 Zhang Jianli,