《咬文嚼字》2009年第3期刊登的谷士锴先生《误说刘、项两件事》一文,批评《庄子智慧全集》中有关的说法。谷先生说“项羽同刘邦争夺韩信之说与史实不符”。并且用《淮阴侯列传》中韩信弃项投刘、登台封帅的事件作为论据进行了论证。其实,这是谷先生的一种误解。因为韩信除了弃项投刘、登坛封帅之事外,另有被封齐王、项羽 “Bitter words” published in 2009 third issue of Mr. Che Shih “misstate Liu, two items,” a text, criticized “Zhuangzi wisdom Complete Works” in the statement. Mr. Gu said “Xiang Yu Liu Bang compete with Han Xin said inconsistent with the historical facts ”. And with the “Huaiyin Hou Biography” in the South Korea vote abandoned items Liu, Feng Shuai handsome event as an argument for argument. In fact, this is Mr. Gu's misunderstanding. Because Han Xin vote in addition to abandon items Liu, Deng Taishun handsome seal, while others were sealed Qi Wang, Xiang Yu