《对外经贸实务》1999年第4期刊登了王树津同志《提单是否是物权凭证之浅见》一文，全文以系统的理论和详实的例证分析厂提单的性质，并认为提单“作为一种债权凭证可能比较适合于物权凭证”。笔者认为．我们固然不能否认提单是一种债权凭证，但也不能否认提单是一种物权凭证。 “Foreign Trade and Economic Cooperation,” 1999 the fourth issue of Comrade Wang Shujin, “whether the bill of lading is a property of the voucher,” a text, the full text of the system theory and detailed examples of the nature of the bill of lading and that the bill of lading “as a debt May be more suitable for property rights certificate. ” the author thinks. While we can not deny that a bill of lading is a debt of credit, we can not deny that a bill of lading is a document of title.