朱光潜先生在《談李白詩三首》(见本刊1958年2月号)里說,《闻王昌龄左迁龙标遙有此寄》“应当作于从流放获赦去金陵之后”。这是不可能的。証据如下: (1)《新唐书·孟浩然传》中記載了王昌龄的事迹:“昌龄字少伯,江宁人。第进士,补秘书郎,又中宏辞,迁汜水尉,不护細行,貶龙标尉。以世乱还乡里,为刺史闾丘晓昕杀。张镐按军河南,兵大集,晓最后期,将戮之。辞曰:‘有亲,乞貸余命!’镐曰:‘王昌龄之亲,欲与誰养?’晓默然。” In his book “Three Poems on Li Bai Poetry” (see our issue in February 1958), Zhu Guangqian said: “I heard that Wang Changling moved the emblem to the left and sent it to Jinling after his release from exile.” This is impossible. The evidence is as follows: (1) “The New Tang Shu Meng Haoran Biography” records Wang Changling’s deeds: “Changling word less Bo, Jiangning people. The first Jinshi, make up the secretary Lang, and the macro speech, Not to protect the thin line, derogatory Longhua Wei .To the reincarnation, for the provincial governor Lu Qiu Xiao Xin kill .Zhang Ho press army Henan, soldier set, Xiao final period, will kill .Rescription: ’Have pro, begging for the remaining ’Pick said:’ Wang Changling’s dear, who wants to raise? ’Xiao silent. ”