论文部分内容阅读
闵大章是《种芹人曹霑画册》中两个署名的题画诗作者之一。黄一农先生依据《吴兴闵氏宗谱》,认定该宗谱中字大章的闵焕元即是《种芹人曹霑画册》中的闵大章,并以此为依据,进一步证明《种芹人曹霑画册》中的种芹人曹霑与《红楼梦》作者曹雪芹为同一人。本文考得,《吴兴闵氏宗谱》中的闵焕元与《种芹人曹霑画册》中的闵大章没有关系;闵焕元与其父亲闵振文父子的“太学生”“礼部儒士”的出身并不确定;闵焕元一支迁居吴兴(今浙江湖州)六百余年,闵焕元不可能还以山东“汶水”称谓其居住地或祖居地;黄先生为证明《种芹人曹霑画册》中种芹人曹霑即《红楼梦》作者曹雪芹观点而假设的前提——《种芹人曹霑画册》是一个完整、不可分割的整体的前提亦不成立。
Min Dazhang is one of the two autographed poetic writers in Cao Zao’s Album of Qin Qin. According to “Wuxing Min’s Genealogy”, Mr. Huang Yi-nong confirmed that Min Huan-yuan, a large-sized chapter in the genealogy, is Min Minzhang in the book “Cao Qin of Ce Qin” and based on this, it further proves that “ Cao Qin in the kind of parsley and Cao Xueqin author of ”Dream of Red Mansions“ for the same person. In this article, Min Huan-yuan in ”Wu Xing Min’s Genealogy“ has nothing to do with Min Dazhang in ”Cao Qin’s Catalog of Qin Qin“; Min Huan-yuan and his father, Min Zhenwen and his son, Not sure; Min Huan yuan moved to Wuxing (now Huzhou, Zhejiang) six hundred years, Min Huan Yuan can not be still Shandong ”Wenshui “ to call his place of residence or ancestral home; Mr. Wong to prove that ” The prerequisite for the assumption that Cao Qin, a man of Chinese origin, Cao Caoqin, the author of A Dream in Red Mansions, is a complete and indivisible whole premise, does not hold.