戴伟华《〈使至塞上〉与崔希逸破吐蕃事无关》一文,认为崔希逸破吐蕃事发生在开元二十五年冬十二月,并认为王维出塞及其《使至塞上》诗创作与崔希逸破吐蕃事无关。但其主要依据《河西破蕃贼露布》实作于天宝元年十二月,且其所记非崔希逸破吐蕃事而是另一位河西节度使王倕破吐蕃事;其所据之敦煌文献吐蕃《大事纪年》之吐蕃“及至牛年”纪事亦不可靠,故戴先生新观点不成立。 Dai Weihua’s article “To Make It Over” and “Cui Xi Yi’s Violation of Tuberculosis”, that Cui Xiyi broke the Tubo incident in the winter of December of the 25th year of the Kaiyuan period and considered that Wang Wei’s blockage and his poetic creation Cui Xi Yi nothing to break the Tubo. However, it is mainly based on “Hexi broken Fan thief Luobu” for the Tianbao first year in December, and his notes non-Cui Xi Yi spit Tubo things but another Hexi Jiedushi Wang Jiu broken Tubo things; its according to Dunhuang Literature Tubo “Events Annals of the Tubo” “to the Year of the Ox” Chronicle is not reliable, so Mr. Dai’s new point of view is not established.