姚洋在今年《读书》第四期上批评我的文章 ,我想做些答辩。我的那篇小文 ,意思非常简单明了 ,无非是说 ,中国农村的自治 ,需要利用传统的自组织资源。历史的经验证明 ,乡村组织资源的破坏 ,国家政权的下移和行政干预是不能逃其咎的 (包括改革前全能式的政权网络 )。而现今以选 Yao Yang criticized my article on the fourth reading of this year’s book, and I would like to reply. My essay, whose meaning is very simple and simple, means nothing more than that the self-government in rural China needs to utilize traditional self-organizing resources. Historical experience proves that the destruction of the resources of rural organizations, the downward movement of state power and the administrative intervention can not be blamed (including the pre-reform all-power regime network). Now choose