对《读<中国书法史·两汉卷>献疑》—文的答复

来源 :中国书画 | 被引量 : 0次 | 上传用户:colinwangaaaa
下载到本地 , 更方便阅读
声明 : 本文档内容版权归属内容提供方 , 如果您对本文有版权争议 , 可与客服联系进行内容授权或下架
论文部分内容阅读
《中国书画》杂志2003年第2期上发表的陆昱华先生《读<中国书法史·两汉卷>献疑》一文,对拙著的研究方法及对人文的关怀作了赞扬,但是对拙著在名物制度方面认为有四个地方可以商榷。我一向认为撰写论著必须要处处能经得起读者的推敲和质疑,所以每下笔总要求言必有据,深思熟虑。对于他能提出不同看法,表示欢迎,但对他所列的依据和发表的见解,我认为或是因未见前人的考释,或以当今的观念去理解古代名物,或援引较后的记载而忽视了更早的文献,都并不正确。今逐一简略地答复批评如下: Lu Yuhua, published in Chinese Calligraphy and Painting Magazine, No. 2, 2003, presented his article with “Doubts about the History of Chinese Calligraphy and the Two Han Dynasties” and praised my research method and care for humanity. However, There are four areas that can be discussed. I always think that the writing must be everywhere can withstand the reader’s scrutiny and questioning, so every time the total demand must be based on data, thoughtful consideration. I welcome the fact that he can make a different point of view. However, I do not think he can understand the ancient names either because he did not find out his predecessors or used his concepts to refer to his later evidence. Ignoring the earlier literature is not correct. Here is a brief summary of the criticisms:
其他文献
会议
The molecular mechanisms of organ size control and regulation remain one of the major unsolved mysteries of development biology.Almost a decade ago,the discover
会议
ZL300(ZDL-12)型载波机通路盘故障查找方法赵荣,石丽华,金炎屹ZL300(ZDL-12)型载波机中,由于通路盘的数量多,故障率相对较高。现就我们近几年查找通路盘故障的实践,介绍快速查找通路盘中调制电路和音频放大器
会议
日历一页页地撕,日子一天天地过,我们的爱情就像在海滩上的图画。海浪冲来,亲吻着沙滩,模糊的是字迹,冲走的是岁月,留下的却是闪亮的砂石或精美的螺贝。    锅碗瓢盆奏响的交响曲,我们的爱情也需要经常“保鲜”。  2010年10月10日是百年一遇的“三连十”,我和妻子也把这一天当作是“十全十美”的好日子,见证我们的“甜蜜爱情”。
会议
1.对手艺的温馨回忆,我的手艺。大约是秋天或者还要晚一些的时候,乡村少年们都偷了自家的小锅铲子去村前一块洼地里挖淤泥。平原上的乡村少年,由此开始了乡村的手工制作。首
会议
会议