论文部分内容阅读
目的评价当前国内已出版的5个针灸临床实践指南的质量,以分析当前针灸临床实践指南的研究现状。方法利用指南质量评价工具“Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II”(AGREE II),由4名评价员分别对每个指南的6个领域进行评估,评价指南质量。结果 5个指南AGREE II的平均得分情况为:范围和目的55%,参与人员27%,制定的严谨性4%,表达的明晰性55%,应用性4%,编辑独立性1%。结论当前针灸领域的专科循证实践指南数量较少,且存在一定的方法学缺陷,其指南质量不高。
Objective To evaluate the quality of five published clinical practice guidelines of acupuncture in China so as to analyze the current research status of acupuncture clinical practice guidelines. Methods Using the guideline quality assessment tool “Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II” (AGREE II), four reviewers evaluated the six fields of each guideline to evaluate the guideline quality. Results The average score of AGREE II in the five guidelines was 55% of scope and purpose, 27% of participants, 4% of rigor formulated, 55% of expressiveness, 4% of applicability, and 1% of editorial independence. Conclusions The current number of specialist evidence-based practice guidelines in the field of acupuncture and moxibustion is relatively small with some methodological flaws and the quality of the guidelines is not high.